Jun 06 2005

Coney Island and Totonno Pizza

Published by Erin at 11:29 pm under Food and Drink, Neighborhood

Coneyisland1

Given the recent interest in Coney Island–to develop or not to develop–and the 90 degree weather Sunday, I decided that the kitschy strip of Brighton Beach needed a visit. Sunday was unbelievably crowded, with all walks of life exposing themselves to the elements. A few things I learned from observance: Seagulls are just as disturbing as pigeons when being fed en masse, Shoot the Freak appeals across social and economic classes, and high-heeled shoes do *not* make for good footwear on the boardwalk. There’s something uniquely Brooklyn about the place, and it seems dangerous to mess with nostalgia. Walk more than a block from the beach, though, and it’s easy to see why this area needs a little economic kick-in-the-ass. It’s not that I want to see the Freak Show or the wonderfully greasy food shacks be pushed out by a beachside Olive Garden, but the area is obviously suffering.

Totonno_1At least half the reason for our trip was Totonno Pizzeria Napolitano. The oldest continuously operating pizza parlor in New York churns out some fantastic thin-crust pies. The freshness of the dough and the cheese blows the competition out of the water. In fact, the place smelled so good that I forgot to take a photo of our pizza until we’d consumed all but the last two pieces–which we promptly ate right after taking this photo.  While waiting for a table outside, we had the chance to talk with a couple who’d been going to the restaurant for the past 20 years. They recommended a few old Brooklyn favorites you may be reading about in the coming weeks.

  • Share/Bookmark

One response so far

One Response to “Coney Island and Totonno Pizza”

  1. Chrison 08 Jun 2005 at 2:39 pm

    Oh, man, I love Totonno’s. I’ve made trips down there just for the pizza.
    The one on the Upper East Side is a bit weird, though; having been to the homey, tiny Coney location a lot, the upscale-ness of that one just makes me feel weird.